Final Post

The website my group chose for our final project is http://www.craigslist.com. For those of you who have never heard of the site it is basically an online classifieds type site offering places for people to both search and post for goods,services, and even jobs. It has local classifieds and forums for over 450 cities worldwide which are community moderated and mostly free. Through research we found that this site was hugely popular receiving over 30 million new classified ads and 9 billion page views each month. For having this much traffic and popularity you could never guess it from the sites homepage.

The site has a very simple homepage design with no graphics and only links to the different locations in a unattractive grid pattern as well as a column on the far left side with a few other options to choose. This website basically looks like it could have been created by anyone who just learned how to insert hyperlinks into an html document. It is only after a user navigates and clicks their state and then their local area that the functionality of the website becomes apparent as the classified categories appear, once again in a giant table of links. Our group discussed this fact that the navigation through this entire process is tedious and finding the correct links were both time consuming due to the quantity and strenuous on the eyes, due to the formatting. These are two problems that a website wishing to provide users with a quick way to view classifieds for their area most definitely would not want their users to experience.

Not only is the design of the website extremely poor in our opinion, but there are many well known sites offering similar services(amazon,ebay,monster) that a user could simply use instead. Why then do you feel that millions of people utilize this service every month instead of other, more specialized services such as ebay? Does the underlying parallel to print classifieds and user’s clear understanding of how those work lead them to prefer this method of searching/posting ? Where is the line ever drawn between usability and presentation; will strong underlying functionality carry a poorly designed product/website, or is it always doomed to eventually fail?

Advertisements

2 Responses to “Final Post”

  1. cmeiers Says:

    I think that a poorly designed website will ultimately lead to its demised. Regardless of how good the functionality is. if the website is poorly designed then no one will want to use it. Design will always reign over functionality.

  2. tspeters Says:

    I think people use this site because it is so defined as to what you are looking for because it is a classifieds web site, but the only problem with that is, what you are looking for may not be in the same city or state and you may not always be able to find what you want like you could from ebay or amazon. I think the only reason why this site works is because it is so simply and that is why people probably like it. It is unorganized to me though, but that may be because I am going to school for stuff like this and I notice things that the average internet user may not care about. I think over time though there will be a much better design of a web site like this and it will be much more user friendly and aesthetically pleasing, which will then bring this site to a halt.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: